Call

Ask a Dietitian

Artificial sweeteners

We’re excited to have launched a brand-new section in Membership Matters: Ask a Dietitian! 

Each month, we’re answering a common nutrition question from our community. This month, we’re exploring a popular one: “Are artificial sweeteners bad for your long-term health?”

Are artificial sweeteners bad for your long-term health?

This is a great question and one that comes up at our programs and events all the time! Artificial sweeteners can cause quite a bit of debate because there is a lot of information available online.

This is a topic where you want to read information from a reliable source and be careful of putting too much trust in someone’s personal opinion.

Some key points about artificial sweeteners and their cancer risk.

The World Health Organisation’s cancer agency (IARC) groups substances based on how strong the evidence is that they could cause cancer. Not how risky they are in everyday life.

They can fall into four possible groups:

  • Group 1 = carcinogenic (strong evidence in humans)
  • Group 2A = probably carcinogenic
  • Group 2B = possibly carcinogenic
  • Group 3 = not classifiable

Artificial sweeteners fall into Group 2B – “possibly carcinogenic”. This means there is some signal, but far from conclusive evidence that artificial sweeteners increase your risk of cancer. Interestingly, red meat (group 2A) and alcohol (group 1) are both higher risk than artificial sweeteners.

The World Health Organisation guidelines recommend not to use artificial sweeteners for weight loss as studies have found that consuming more products with artificial sweeteners does not help you to lose weight. Long term use of artificial sweeteners also does not help reduce your risk of type 2 diabetes.

Artificial sweeteners are usually found in food or drinks that are highly processed. They also often contain minimal nutrition. It is not recommended to consume these products regularly. They offer minimal health benefits and may also contain high levels of saturated fat and salt which are harmful to your health if eaten often.

Having artificially sweetened products every now and then is unlikely to harm your health, so I wouldn’t stress about having a diet coke once a week. The bigger issue is for those that have made it a habit and consume large amounts.

A good rule of thumb is to aim to base your diet on wholefoods that are minimally processed. Treat both added sugars and artificial sweeteners as ‘sometimes’ foods rather than everyday foods.

Author Charlotte Lentfer, dietitian and credentialled diabetes educator

Have your say

If there is a topic/question you’d like us to cover in a future edition, please click the link below – we’d love to hear from you! 

Submit your question

Previous questions

Skip to content